There was only one time that I ever witnessed an adult hush a
child when asked about an individual’s disability. I was standing in the checkout
line at a grocery store reading one of the magazines that stand on the racks close
to the front of the line when I heard the mom in front of me say to her son “
Zac, it’s not nice to point, keep your hand down”. This got my attention and
was now curious as to what the boy was reacting to. I lunged forward to put the
magazine back down when I heard the mom say a little more sternly to her son
now “Zac, I will talk to you about it when we leave. Hush”. As I looked around
the little boy to take a glimpse at the individual in front of him, I noticed
the woman checking out, on the line in front, only had one arm. I guess the woman
heard the boy ask a question to her mom and she turned around. Zac’s mom
whispered “I’m sorry”. The woman just smiled and turned back around.
I can see how the mom’s reluctance to speak to her son about
what he noticed regarding the woman in front
of him can send him a message of not to notice differences in others and ask
questions. It’s important that children know it is OK to ask questions about
differences they notice in others because this is how we develop acceptance and
politeness. It is especially crucial when children are interacting and learning
together in an inclusive classroom As Derman-Sparks and Edwards (2010, p. 125) “all children-those who are
typically developing and children with disabilities- need to be able to ask
questions, get accurate information, explore their feelings, and learn positive
ways to interact with their peers”. I feel it’s important that children
understand how to be polite when asking questions to others with disabilities
and not to hurt their feelings. Many people that I have come across with
certain disabilities don’t mind sharing information and asking questions about
what happened to them and how they get by on a daily basis. Although, I know it
can be a sensitive topic to some and they choose not to converse with others. I
feel it is important children understand this as well, that some individuals
will feel more comfortable than others and not to be discouraged if someone
chooses not to answer their questions. If I was in that situation, at the
moment I realized the woman heard my son being inquisitive about her one arm, I
would have politely asked the woman if my son could ask her a question. I feel
the woman would instantly know what kind of question he would be asking. It
could be a great learning experience for all. As anti-bias educators we need to
support children in “developing cognitive and emotional strategies to know what
they want to say and be able to say it” (Derman-Sparks & Edwards, 2010, p.
127).
References
Derman-Sparks,
L., & Olsen Edwards, J. (2010). Anti-bias education for young
children and ourselves. Washington, DC: NAEYC.
I really appreciate your different outlook on this situation. I hadn't considered how important it is to teach children appropriate ways to ask questions in order to teach them how to be polite when doing so. When we hush children it makes them feel bad for asking and it makes it also makes other people feel bad for being different. I would agree that most people would feel more comfortable answering children's questions than seeing them be silenced or scolded for those questions or observations. However, if people do respond badly then children need to understand why. Great post!
ReplyDeleteHi Kristen
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your experience and insights. I really like your perspective in this situation. This has been a great learning activity as I never fathomed how essential teaching children appropriate ways to communicate was to enhancing politeness.
Great post!
Kristen, thank you for this great post!!! Sometimes we find children funny and even charming when they ask for something in an indirect way (if only I had a candy). When we respond to these situations with what children expect (give them a candy) we are encouraging them to do it even more. We sometimes overlook the importance of teaching them to ask directly and respectfully what they want.
ReplyDeleteAs you mentioned in your post, asking questions the right way is something we have to teach them.